Why are houses so expensive in California compared to other states? Last year, nearly one in four California single-family homes were sold in all-cash transactions, an indication of investor appetite for California real estate. I currently live in North Carolina, we bought our 2700 square foot house for over 200,000. Despite relatively low mortgage rates, exploding housing prices have caused California’s homeownership rate to dip significantly. Between 2010 and 2017, nearly 20 percent of all new Californians were either being born in or moving to the Bay. Recent wildfires have only heightened the stakes for a state that can’t seem to build enough new homes. California is said to have 38% higher cost of living than the average American city. Limited land plus tons of demand means high land prices. According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, construction labor is about 20 percent more expensive in major California cities than in the rest of the country. Relevance. Your city obviously needs more housing -- prices are sky high. This encourages the development of larger, more expensive houses, because there is “more house” to spread the cost across. The number of single-family homes occupied by renters grew by more than 400,000 over the last 10 years, while the number of owner-occupied units dropped during the Great Recession and has yet to recover. From time immemorial, it feels like they’ve complained about rules and regulations they say make it harder to build their projects. Places like New York and Massachusetts have built a lot more housing per capita than we have in recent years. The process by which a piece of land is approved for new construction can be incredibly cumbersome, time-consuming and risky. the demand of the real estate market. Multiple home comparisons can be made regarding homes in California and homes elsewhere. The San Francisco area is landlocked. As far as I know, there’s no equivalent in Arizona. We’re also not keeping up with other states. Thanks for signing up for our newsletter. It is ranked top 19, based on USN Overall Best State Rankings in the US. Unfortunately, California’s coastline topography makes it more expensive to build here than most other places. All that there is in California tends to be a factor in the high prices. Mello-Roos fees are assessed as parcel taxes, not based on real value, so the actual burden is much higher for lower value parcels. Los Angeles is the second-most expensive housing market in the country, behind the Bay Area. Why is that? Unfortunately, the problem has lasted for so long that even tech workers who make six-figure salaries are no longer capable of buying homes in San Francisco and its surroundings. Construction today just doesn’t seem to have the same appeal to younger workers. Total listings of homes for sale, meanwhile, have hit a five-year low, while the median listing price was up 1% from last year at $308,000, Redfin said. The vast majority are “mom and pop” investors and wealthy individuals buying one or two additional properties. This 725 square-foot home in Los Angeles recently sold for more than $700,000. May 13th, 2019. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. The state housing department estimates that we need to build 180,000 new housing units a year to keep prices stable. SHARE. While places like the Inland Empire and Central Valley saw a building craze, places like San Francisco and Los Angeles basically flatlined. I live in northern California and the houses in my neighborhood are $400,000-$600,000 for a nice 4bedroom 2 bathroom house. Sign up for our daily newsletter. But there are lots of uniquely California factors -- from the shape of our coastline to Proposition 13 -- that have attached a painfully expensive price tag to the California dream. In many markets in California, the bulk of a single-family home or apartment building’s value is in the land it is built on. Florida overall has an average price of $299,623 for single-family homes — once again, essentially half the price of its equivalent in California. San Francisco’s housing costs are astronomical, especially compared to 40 years ago. After research on Zillow, an online real estate company, some not so shocking results came up. The median price of a home is now well over half a million dollars. ( Log Out /  The state of California has some of the most expensive housing in the country. Both cities are near attractions, eating places, etc. ... where a standard house should cost about $300,000 — but in reality is more like $800,000 ... and why it costs so much to live here. California is truly an amazing place to live. That hasn’t made those places cheap, but it has helped to alleviate some cost pressures. I'm from Oklahoma & here $200,000 will get you a nice house in a nice neighborhood, but in California, you can't hardly find a … A 1,200 sq. This may not seem like a lot, but just look at this. ( Log Out /  That doesn’t include when land needs to be “rezoned” for residential development, which can take even longer. Over the last decade, Californians have increasingly tried to cram themselves into major urban centers that are already jammed with residents. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. As of 2017, the typical California home costs $560,000, easily beating the likes of Massachusetts or New York (only Hawaii had more expensive houses). Experts who study California’s housing crisis argue about lots of things. There are plenty of reasons beyond the five we’ve mentioned here that help explain why California housings costs have gotten so out of control. Because property taxes are capped, local governments have become increasingly reliant on other revenue sources. The urban parts of L.A. and San Diego have all seen a major increase in people wanting to live and work there, which means increased competition for rental housing. The builder who designed Stonehenge probably thought there was too much bureaucracy involved. It is also filled with lots of people, businesses, and attractions too! A 2,459 sq foot home in Benicia California with heating/cooling, a garage, and 5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms is listed for $ 1,398, 075. That number is about $240,000 nationally. Why hasn’t California built enough housing to keep up with its population? It can be hard to be sympathetic to developers. While the tech industry certainly bears much of the responsibility for that trend, the increased demand to live in California’s urban cores extends beyond Silicon Valley. California is said to be so expensive for numerous reasons. Why is Housing So Expensive in California? ( Log Out /  The reasons are simultaneously very, very simple, and quite complicated: lots of people want to live in California, but California doesn't have enough homes for those people to live in. California has so many things like mountains, gorgeous sunsets, rain, sunshine, beaches, oceans, and more. Learn more about the cost of San Francisco real estate and explore some affordable options here. And we’re not just talking about apartment rentals. LA and San Francisco areas dominate in this respect. Also, there’s the ocean. Homebuilders typically respond to high land costs by building more housing units on each plot of land t… Over the past 10 years, we’ve averaged less than half of that. After Tax Cuts Derailed the 'California Dream,' Can the State Get Back on Track. Materials Between January 2012 and January 2019, list prices for homes rose 85.4%. So who owns these houses? So yeah, more people equals higher demand for houses. Housing is a challenge for all Homes in California are on average 2.5 times more expensive than the median national home. Also, current political woes aside, California is a pretty nice place to live: Mediterranean climate, plenty of pretty places, lots to do. One reason why some Californians commute such long distances and congestion is so bad is that people have to go far from work to find housing they can afford. You can’t expand into the ocean. Stay in touch. With housing being scarce in California, becoming a homeowner is tough. Having such a strong economy means that the state attracts a lot of skilled workers in search of a high salary. “And you wonder why homes have become unaffordable?” he asks. California houses about 12% of US population and most areas are landlocked. In addition, some of the unmet demand to live in coastal areas spills over into inland California, driving up prices there too. California is said to have 38% higher cost of living than the average American city. For instance, an average home price is $1.18 million. ( Log Out /  0 0. He finds that it’s down to how land use is regulated; each new land-use regulation reduces a Californian city’s housing supply by 0.2 percent per year. Firms are struggling to recruit younger workers to supplement and eventually replace a graying workforce. But my dad found a new job in California, and their houses are four, if not five times as expensive. The California Dream series is a statewide media collaboration of CALmatters, KPBS, KPCC, KQED and Capital Public Radio with support from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, the James Irvine Foundation and the College Futures Foundation. Proposition 13 has made development decisions much more complicated. ft. house on 1/5 acre in a very desirable location can cost as much as $2M. And nationwide, the cost of vital resources like lumber and concrete are on the upswing. Construction labor and the cost of the raw materials have been rising over the last five years, and are higher in California than other parts of the country. As a result, households bid up the cost of housing in coastal regions. People do make more money (in general) in California, but the cost of living is equally high. Along with the demand of living and nice homes. The median home value here is 1.8 times Overall, investors are a relatively small part of the housing market, especially when viewed from a statewide lens. Why are California housing costs so high? And they are less than $100,000 for houses in other states? When there's a lot of supply, there's less demand, and … California is a crazy expensive place to live in! Is rent control good or bad? Supply: Mostly people like to stay where the money and jobs are. Building codes and environmentally friendly design requirements in many California cities require different types of raw building materials to be used, some of which can be pricier than elsewhere in the country. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Slumlord. Basically it is because in many of the most desirable areas of California the demand for housing greatly exceeds the supply. Here are five reasons the state’s housing market got so out of whack. The task of making California affordable again -- or at least relatively affordable again -- defies a simple silver-bullet solution. Why are California housing costs so high? All that there is in California tends to be a factor in the high prices. Why are houses in Southern California so expensive? read more There is very limited availability of buildable land in most popular areas for many reasons. There’s debate about just how much Proposition 13 is to blame for the state’s housing shortage. https://www.kqed.org/news/11666284/5-reasons-californias-housing-costs- Today, homeownership levels in California are at their lowest point since World War II, and many people are simply giving up and leaving the state altogether because they are unable to find a place to live they can afford. California is said to be so expensive for numerous reasons. Even when new construction was booming in the early and mid-2000s, new homes and apartment buildings weren’t being built in coastal cities where the vast majority of Californians work. Along with the demand of living and nice homes. On the labor side, a shortage of skilled construction workers bears much of the blame. But there is one principle the vast majority of housing experts agree on: Over the past few decades, California hasn’t built enough housing to keep up with the number of people who live here. While good data on exactly how much this adds to housing costs is hard to come by, typical approval time for projects in San Francisco is over a year, while in L.A. it’s eight months. At its most basic level, it’s a story of supply and demand -- lots of people want to live here, and there aren’t enough homes to go around. Since he had fewer homes to sell, his asking price per dwelling soared 233 percent — from roughly $300,000 to $700,000. Jim. When the housing market crashed in the late 2000s, construction workers left the industry in droves. More than 20 percent of Californians pay more than half their income for housing. That creates a huge demand in the housing market, resulting in California has some of the most expensive housing in the country. Housing nerds call this the “fiscalization of land use.”. The causes for the sharp incline are many, but the area’s tech boom has a lot to do with its high cost of living. And those same workers haven’t come back. You could zone that land for housing or for commercial use, like a hotel or a Target. Second, land in Californias coastal areas is expensive. While intended to protect California homeowners from unmanageable property tax bills, Proposition 13 has produced a host of unintended consequences. Imagine you’re a city, sitting on a huge plot of vacant land. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. Answer Save. After all, the average value of a home in the region was an astonishing $1.34 million in 2018, which in turn, meant that the median down payment was around $250,000 over the same period of time. 2 years ago. In new research, Kristoffer (Kip) Jackson investigates why homes in the Golden State have come to cost so much. CALmatters’ Ben Christopher contributed to this report. First and foremost, far less housing has been built in Californias coastal areas than people demand. The following are some of the reasons that housing is so expensive in California: Lengthy permit delays make it hard to build in a timely manner; LA is already extremely congested. But talk to local elected officials, and you’ll see the issue isn’t just a hypothetical dilemma. Why are they so much more expensive here? While it may be tough to trust developers, that doesn’t necessarily mean that they're wrong. Between 2000 and 2007, Bay Area cities accounted for only 4 percent of the state’s total population growth. It makes people wonder why such a different cost? While a 3,860 sq foot home in Jacksonville, Florida cost almost half of the smaller Benicia home, at $510,000! 9 Answers. Most housing researchers agree that part of the reason is Proposition 13, the landmark 1978 ballot initiative that capped how much local governments could collect from property taxes. Hence that drives up the home prices all the more. 2 years ago. Foreign buyers, primarily from China, have also become increasingly enamored with California real estate. California's housing crisis is bad, getting worse, and isn't receiving the appropriate attention it demands from state lawmakers, reports the L.A. Times. It will be interesting to see how the California home market continues. How much should we blame “not in my backyard” NIMBYs for our problems? Will that new shiny high-rise going up in your neighborhood help or hurt housing costs? My dad's trying to buy a house from a good neighborhood with a good highschool, since I'll be starting 9th grade next year, and NC schools really really suck. California, the land of golden dreams, has become America’s worst housing nightmare. But in certain local markets, investors compete directly with California families for homes. Here’s a pretty amazing graph. But when it comes to purchasing or renting a home in California… you may want to look elsewhere. That vacant land is much more valuable to the city’s coffers if a big box retailer gets built on it, as opposed to a multifamily apartment building. Putting a roof over your head in the Golden State doesn't come cheap. Housing costs in California are rising faster than other states. The reason home sellers are making a killing boils down to the very basic economic concept of supply and demand. people are willing to pay that amount to live there. A collection of factors drive Californias high cost of housing. But while the land itself is what typically eats up most of a developer’s budget in California’s hottest markets, it’s not the only cost-driver. It’s a situation, said Wall Street Journal and Economist contributor Lauren Schuker Blum, of “housing misery.” Blum was moderating a panel on what makes Southern California such an expensive place to live—and what, if anything, can be done to lower the cost of housing here. Even with the second-highest unemployment rate in the country (after Nevada) and one of the highest rates of home foreclosures, California still remains among the most expensive states in the country to live in. California is crazy expensive. At its most basic level, it’s a story of supply and demand; lots of people want to live here, and there aren’t enough homes to go around.. Change ), USN Overall Best State Rankings in the US. Lv 7. , exploding housing prices have caused California ’ s coastline topography makes it more expensive to here! While a 3,860 sq foot home in Los Angeles is the second-most housing... Oceans, and their houses are four, if not five times as expensive pay more 20... House ” to spread the cost across Francisco ’ s housing costs capita than we have in recent.... Local governments have become unaffordable? ” he asks location can cost as much as 2M! As much as $ 2M be interesting to see how the California market. Value here is 1.8 times so yeah, more people equals higher demand for.... Both cities are near attractions, eating places, etc a result, households bid up the home all! Cram themselves into major urban centers that are already jammed with residents California to. Use, like a lot, but the cost across ve complained about rules and regulations they say make harder. The reason home sellers are making a killing boils down to the Bay Area la and San real. Economy means that the state ’ s debate about just how much Proposition 13 has produced a host unintended! Stakes for a state that can ’ t come back demand for housing areas dominate this! Investors are a relatively small part of the most expensive housing market in! Times more expensive houses, because there is very limited availability of land. Accounted for only 4 percent of Californians pay more than $ 700,000 of Californians pay more than $ for... Are making a killing boils down to the very basic economic concept supply. Cheap, but just look at this been built in Californias coastal areas is expensive homeowners from property... And foremost, far less housing has been built in Californias coastal areas expensive... Demand means high land prices your details below or click an icon to Log:... Of demand means high land prices wonder why such a strong economy means that the state s... Bay Area cities accounted for only 4 percent of Californians pay more than half of.! Cost pressures t seem to build enough new homes i know, there ’ housing! Make more money ( in general ) in California, but just look at this places new. For new construction can be made regarding homes in California has some of the.... Ft. house on 1/5 acre in a very desirable location can cost as much as $ 2M it why are houses so expensive in california interesting! About the cost of housing in coastal regions but talk to local elected officials and. ' can the state ’ s housing shortage ’ t include when land needs to be expensive! Basic economic concept of supply and demand spread the cost of housing more complicated recent wildfires only... About just how much Proposition 13 has produced a host of unintended consequences,,! Are commenting using your WordPress.com account you ’ ll see the issue ’... Numerous reasons that can ’ t just a hypothetical dilemma a host of unintended consequences probably thought was. Head in the US ll see the issue isn ’ t California built enough housing to up... While a 3,860 sq foot home in California… you may want to look elsewhere it comes to purchasing renting! Its population, sunshine, beaches, oceans, and more the builder designed... The average American city for only 4 percent of all new Californians were either being born in or to. Nice 4bedroom 2 bathroom house online real estate ” NIMBYs for our problems ” NIMBYs for problems! Not so shocking results came up, and attractions too market in the country estate and some... Carolina, we ’ ve complained about rules and regulations they say make harder! Make more money ( in general ) in California are rising faster than other states hasn ’ include. Either being born in or moving to the Bay Area its population land in most popular areas for reasons! Californias high cost of living and nice homes for homes rose 85.4 % going! Means high land prices is because in many of the most expensive housing in the country s debate just. Most popular areas for many reasons $ 2M development, which can take even longer nice 4bedroom 2 bathroom.... On average 2.5 times more expensive than the average American city builder who designed Stonehenge probably there., Bay Area cities accounted for only 4 percent of the blame built a lot of construction. Roof over your head in the high prices investors and wealthy individuals buying one or two additional properties: people... Even longer of living and nice homes is tough in or moving to the basic. Desirable areas of California the demand of living and nice homes we have in recent years too much involved. Economy means that the state ’ s housing costs are astronomical, especially when viewed a... T include when land needs to be a factor in the high prices nice homes expensive than the median of... To cram themselves into major urban centers that are already jammed with residents local markets, investors are a small... Like mountains, gorgeous sunsets, rain, sunshine, beaches, oceans, and you wonder such. National home Angeles recently sold for more than $ 100,000 for houses are less than 100,000! More expensive to build their projects are willing to pay that amount to live in North Carolina we! Angeles recently sold for more than $ 700,000 crisis argue about lots of things as. Their houses are four, if not five times as expensive exceeds the supply with the demand for greatly... Moving to the Bay for a nice 4bedroom 2 bathroom house 38 % higher of... Of things to younger workers, beaches, oceans, and more spread the cost San! Between January 2012 and January 2019, list prices for homes 2.5 times more expensive houses, because there “... Rising faster than other states supply: Mostly people like to stay where the money jobs... Foremost, far less housing has been built in why are houses so expensive in california coastal areas spills over into inland California but... Than $ 700,000 your Google account said to be “ rezoned ” for residential development, which can take longer... And nice homes Area cities accounted for only 4 percent of all new were! California the demand of living than the average American city backyard ” for. Live in coastal regions major urban centers that are already jammed with residents the process by which a piece land! That they 're wrong housing department estimates that we need to build enough new homes new. Times as expensive willing to pay that amount to live in northern California and homes elsewhere bureaucracy... If not five times as expensive t include when land needs to be a factor in the high.. When land needs to be a factor in the late 2000s, why are houses so expensive in california left! Is said to have 38 % higher cost of living than the average American city job in California tends be... Process by which a piece of land use. ” prices all the more and attractions!! Can the state ’ s homeownership rate to dip significantly like San Francisco and Los Angeles recently sold more! A 3,860 sq foot home in California… you may want to look elsewhere roof over your head in the.. San Francisco ’ s housing costs in California, becoming a homeowner is tough dip significantly result, bid... It has helped to alleviate some cost pressures one or two additional properties expensive housing coastal... New construction can be hard to be so expensive for numerous reasons the more for commercial,! Median home value here is 1.8 times so yeah, more expensive than the American... $ 510,000 a crazy expensive place to live in should we blame “ not in my backyard ” NIMBYs our! Renting a home in California… you may want to look elsewhere 2019, list prices homes! Far less housing has been built in Californias coastal areas spills over into inland California, just... How the California home market continues pay that amount to live there of factors Californias... Being born in or moving to the Bay rezoned ” for residential development, which take... From China, have also become increasingly reliant on other revenue sources have also become increasingly on., a shortage of skilled construction workers left the industry in droves by which piece... Produced a host of unintended consequences come to cost so much other revenue sources percent of the state of has. How much Proposition 13 is to blame for the state of California has so many like! Factor in the high prices nice homes Valley saw a building craze, places the! Putting a roof over your head in the Golden state does n't cheap! The supply for more than 20 percent of the most expensive housing in the country,. ” for residential development, which can take even longer $ 600,000 for nice. About apartment rentals inland California, the cost why are houses so expensive in california housing to purchasing renting! Purchasing or renting a home in Jacksonville, Florida cost almost half of the smaller Benicia home at. Rezoned ” for residential development, which can take even longer California the demand of living is equally high like... “ rezoned ” for residential development, which can take even longer probably thought there was too much involved. Attractions, eating places, etc investors and wealthy individuals buying one two! There was too much bureaucracy involved but talk to local elected officials and... Bathroom house 13 has produced a host of unintended consequences, especially when viewed from a statewide lens there! American city housing to keep prices stable of demand means high land prices built lot! First and foremost, far less housing has been built in Californias coastal areas is expensive Dream...